Aftermesh logoAftermesh
Amazon seller guides

Amazon Order Defect Rate: What Counts Toward the 1%

Last updated November 2026

A buyer leaves you a 1-star today on an order from 70 days ago. It still drags down the feedback percentage buyers see. It no longer touches ODR.

ODR is the share of your seller-fulfilled orders in a 60-day period that had at least one defect: negative seller feedback, an A-to-Z claim, or a credit card chargeback. Amazon requires it under 1%. Above that, it may restrict your selling privileges, including suspension of seller-fulfilled offers.

One order counts once, even if it has all three defects.

Which orders does ODR cover?

"Order defect rate (ODR) measures a seller’s customer service quality. ODR is the percentage of orders with one or more of the following indicators of poor customer service during a given 60-day period: Negative feedback (1- and 2-star seller reviews), A-to-z Guarantee claims, Credit card chargebacks."

"ODR only applies to seller-fulfilled orders."

"An order has a defect if it results in negative feedback, an A-to-z Guarantee claim that is not denied, or a credit card chargeback."

Amazon, Order defect rate, Seller Central help

If you sell both FBA and FBM, only the FBM orders go into ODR, so compare the rate with that order count, not with total sales. If you sell only through FBA, ODR doesn't cover your orders at all.

What does 1% mean in orders?

"Our policy is that sellers maintain an order defect rate under 1% in order to sell on Amazon."

Amazon, Order defect rate, Seller Central help

The line is under 1%, not 1% or less. At low volume, that difference is the whole verdict.

  • 100 orders. One defect is 1.00%. That fails. Zero is the only passing count.
  • 300 orders. Two defects are 0.67%. The third puts you at 1.00%.
  • 1,000 orders. Nine defects are 0.90%. The tenth puts you at 1.00%.
  • 3,000 orders. Twenty-nine defects are 0.97%. The thirtieth puts you at 1.00%.

Which negative feedback counts?

A 1-star left today on a 70-day-old order is outside the 60-day window. A 1-star left today on a 10-day-old order is inside it. The feedback percentage buyers see is calculated by the date the feedback arrived, so the two numbers will disagree.

"One- and two-star ratings are considered negative."

"This metric is order-correlated, meaning we look at the date of the order (not the date on which the feedback was received) when computing the rate."

"If a buyer withdraws negative feedback, it is not counted as part of ODR. However, it might take up to 48 hours after a buyer has removed it to disappear from the metric."

Amazon, Order Defect Rate (PDF)

Start with the cause before you ask for removal. Work the buyer through Feedback Manager or the Buyer-Seller Messaging templates; if the feedback meets the removal criteria, request removal in Feedback Manager. The criteria, and the rule against asking the buyer to remove it, are in the seller feedback article.

Which A-to-Z claims count?

"The A-to-z Guarantee Claim Rate (represented as a percentage) is the number of orders with a relevant claim divided by the number of orders in a given 60-day time period."

"The following types of claims impact your ODR:"

  • "Claims that are granted to the buyer and for which, Amazon determines that you were at fault"
  • "Claims for which you refunded the buyer after the claim was filed"
  • "Claims for which you or Amazon canceled the order"
  • "Claims that are pending a decision on appeal"
Amazon, Order defect rate, Seller Central help

"The following types of claims do not impact your ODR:"

  • "Claims for which, Amazon determines that you were not at fault"
  • "Claims that are denied to the buyer"
  • "Claims that were withdrawn by the buyer"
  • "Claims within the A-to-z Guarantee claims process for property damage and personal injury"

"If an appeal decision is overturned, and the seller is found not to be at fault, the claim will be removed from the ODR."

Amazon, Order defect rate, Seller Central help

Sellers often assume a refund or an appeal clears the claim. Neither does: a refund after the claim was filed still counts, and a claim waiting for an appeal decision still counts.

Amazon removes a claim from ODR when it decides you were not at fault, when the claim is denied or withdrawn, or when an appeal overturns the decision and finds you were not at fault.

Do credit card chargebacks count?

Only service chargebacks count.

"The Credit Card Chargeback Rate (represented as a percentage) is the number of orders that have received a credit card chargeback divided by the number of orders in the relevant period."

"A credit card chargeback is similar to an A-to-z Guarantee claim except that the credit card issuer processes the claim and makes the decision, not Amazon."

"Possible problems might include:"

  • "The buyer claims they didn't receive the item."
  • "The buyer returned the item, but didn't receive a refund."
  • "The buyer received a damaged or defective product."

"Amazon does not count fraudulent transaction chargebacks towards your ODR."

Amazon, Order Defect Rate (PDF)

A fraud chargeback is a buyer saying they never made the purchase. A service chargeback is a buyer who acknowledges the purchase but tells the card issuer there was a problem.

The card issuer makes the decision, so whatever you submit goes into that chargeback dispute.

What happens above 1%?

"An order defect rate above 1% may result in a restriction of your selling privileges, including suspension of seller-fulfilled offers."

"For eligible sellers, the option will appear in the banner at the top of your Account Health page where you will be given an opportunity to take a five-question quiz regarding the ODR policy."

"You have 72 hours to take the quiz."

Amazon, Order defect rate, Seller Central help

If you're eligible for the quiz, passing it means no plan of action is required. It doesn't change the metric itself. The orders in the window still have to age out or be removed for one of the reasons above.

If your offers were already suspended, the same help page names the way back: submit an appeal from Account Health with a plan of action to get them reinstated.

To see the number and download the report: Account Health > Customer Service Performance > View details > Order Defect Rate > Download Report.

How do I bring ODR down?

Say 40 orders went out with the wrong power adapter. All 40 sit in the denominator; the ones that complain become the defects.

Fix the component that actually produced the defect. A reply template does nothing for a chargeback, and a refund does nothing for a claim Amazon already counted.

For feedback, read the comment and fix what it names. For an A-to-Z claim, read the claim reason and answer it with the records for that order. For a chargeback, the dispute type tells you whether it's fraud or service, and the service ones need an answer.

A defect stays in the 60-day window until the order ages out. The next batch is the part you can still change; the orders already counted stay until the window ends.

Give the buyer a page of yours

A buyer with a problem can leave seller feedback, open an A-to-Z claim, or call the card issuer. All three can end up in ODR. Aftermesh adds a care page of yours as well.

With Aftermesh you create a page under your own brand and generate the QR code for its insert card. A buyer who scans it describes the order in their own language, and you read it in your dashboard. At the end, the page invites them to leave a review on Amazon. It doesn't connect to your seller account.

Set up a care link

FAQ

What is a good Order Defect Rate on Amazon?

Under 1%. Exactly 1.00% is not under 1%, so it fails the standard.

Does ODR include FBA orders?

No. Amazon says ODR only applies to seller-fulfilled orders, so FBA orders are outside both the numerator and the denominator.

Do product reviews count toward ODR?

No. ODR counts 1- and 2-star seller feedback, A-to-Z claims and credit card chargebacks. A product review is not one of them.

I refunded an A-to-Z claim. Why is it still in my ODR?

A refund after the claim was filed is one of the claim types Amazon counts. Refunding does not remove it; a denial, a withdrawal, a not-at-fault decision or a successful appeal does.

Can a buyer remove negative seller feedback?

Yes. If the buyer withdraws it, it stops counting toward ODR, though Amazon says it can take up to 48 hours to disappear from the metric.

Why does my feedback percentage not match my ODR?

ODR uses the order date. The percentage buyers see uses the date the feedback arrived, so the same feedback can sit in one number and not the other.

What is the 72-hour ODR quiz?

If you're eligible, Account Health may show a five-question quiz. You have 72 hours to take it, and passing it means no plan of action is required.

Further reading: Removing negative seller feedback | The four FBM shipping metrics | The Request a Review button | Voice of the Customer and NCX

This article reflects our own view and isn't platform or legal advice.

Republishing You are welcome to republish this guide, in whole or in part, as long as you credit Aftermesh and keep a link to the original: https://aftermesh.com/guides/amazon-order-defect-rate